Rockwall Herald-Banner (Texas)

Opinion

December 9, 2009

Scents and Sensibility: When evidence doesn't pass the smell test (part one)

LEGALLY SPEAKING

By John Browning



"So lay Argo about the house, all shivering with dog-ticks. Yet the instant Odysseus approached, the dog knew him."

— Homer, The Odyssey

Odysseus' elderly dog Argos may have instantly recognized the scent of his long-lost master, but don't count Michael Buchanek among the believers in the infallibility of a dog's olfactory abilities. Buchanek, you see, was initially identified as the prime suspect in the March 2006 strangulation murder of his friend and neighbor Sally Blackwell, not because of any crime scene evidence but instead on the strength of the highly controversial use of so-called dog-scent lineups. Although Buchanek was later cleared, his civil lawsuit and those of several other Texas men who were wrongfully convicted on the basis of such dog-scent "evidence" have focused attention on the use of such methods and on the larger issue of the prevalence of "junk science" in Texas courts. In this series, we'll examine the use of dog-scent lineups, hear from both critics and proponents of the practice as a forensic tool, and examine the use of dog scent evidence in the context of the larger debate over forensic science scandals in Texas.

The highly sensitive noses of dogs have long proved helpful in tracking people — not just criminal suspects, but also lost individuals. They've been used to locate the bodies of crime victims as well as victims of building collapses and natural disasters. And, of course, we're accustomed to the use of drug — and explosive-sniffing canines. In dog-scent lineups, unlike other uses, the dogs in question are employed not to locate someone, but instead to pick a suspect's smell out of a group. Law enforcement investigators get a scent from items found at a crime scene, and transfer the scent by rubbing a gauze pad on the source item or by rubbing the pad on someone’s body or clothes. The gauze pad is then placed in a container (usually a tin can).

A “lineup” of such containers with pads bearing individual scents from the possible suspect and others not associated with the crime then takes place. A handler gives the dog the scent it's looking for, and then walks it down the line of containers. According to proponents of such lineups, the dog (usually a bloodhound) will give a signal to its handler — stiffening, barking, etc. — upon finding a can with a matching scent. Critics of dog scent lineups say that the methodology is lacking in reliability, any regulatory system to measure a dog's accuracy, and too often is nothing more than a "dog trick" used to justify the suspicions of local law enforcement.

Michael Buchanek knows all too well about such suspicions. Before being implicated as a suspect in Sally Blackwell's murder, Buchanek had served with the Victoria County Sheriff's Office for over 25 years, most recently as a commander of operations.

Yet in March 2006, he found himself on the other side of the interrogation table after dogs belonging to Fort Bend County Sheriffs Deputy Keith Pikett "identified" his scent. After Blackwell's body was found in a field several miles from her home, Pikett's bloodhounds sniffed crime scene evidence, including the rope used to strangle her. The dogs then "matched" the scent to Buchanek. For five months, the veteran officer protested his innocence even as his former colleagues believed the dogs over Buchanek. The cloud of suspicion was lifted only when DNA evidence implicated another man, Jeffrey Grimsinger. Grimsinger later pleaded guilty to the crime.

Earlier this year, Buchanek filed a lawsuit against Keith Pikett, the Victoria County Sheriff's Office, and the Victoria Police Department alleging that his constitutional rights were violated when he was falsely accused. He points to the mental anguish he suffered and is seeking unspecified damages. His attorney, Rex Easley, faults Pikett for devising "an unreliable dog trick" and leading the dogs. Pikett's lawyer, Fort Bend Assistant County Attorney Randall Morse, denies the allegations, saying the trail that led to Buchanek was valid.

"Pikett doesn't arrest anybody," he points outs. "Our dogs don't say 'You murdered somebody.' They don't even say, 'You committed a crime.' They just say 'We picked up your scent.' As for dog-scent lineups in general, Victoria County Sheriff T. Michael O'Connor calls them a "a vital tool in working toward a determination of a case. We will use them again if it merits this type of service."

However, the Buchanek case is hardly an isolated incident. It is just one of a half-dozen civil suits that have been filed to date against Pikett and his superiors by people jailed or imprisoned because of his controversial dog-scent lineups. At least 3 of these lawsuits have been brought with the assistance of lawyer Jeff Blackburn, who serves as general counsel for the Innocence Project of Texas, an organization that works on behalf of the wrongly accused.

One of the plaintiffs is 40 year-old Ronald Curtis. In August 2007, Curtis was arrested following a routine traffic stop when tools in his vehicle aroused the suspicions of police investigating a string of burglaries. A detective's hunch led to a dog-scent lineup with Pikett and his bloodhounds; based on the dog picking out Curtis' scent, Curtis was arrested and spent 8 months in jail. In his case, the scent lineup appeared to outweigh other contradictory evidence, including store security videos depicting a burglar who looked nothing like Curtis.

Meanwhile, the work of other detectives led to the arrest of the actual criminal right after another burglary was committed. Although Curtis was released, he remains understandably bitter about his incarceration and about Pikett’s role.

"This man is a fraud — there needs to be a federal investigation," he says. "No one listened to me. I had four lawyers and finally had to represent myself to get the charges dropped."

Forty-one-year-old Cedric Johnson and 50 year-old Curvis Bickham share Curtis' frustration. Both men were arrested and charged with capital murder in connection with a triple homicide in southeast Houston. Houston police solicited Pikett's help with a dog-scent lineup, and Pikett and his canines were only too happy to oblige, swiftly matching the scent from a charred gas can found at the crime scene to Johnson and Bickham. Despite their claims of innocence (in Bickham's case, his poor health and partial blindness made it especially unlikely that he could have pulled off the triple slaying), Bickham spent eight months in jail while Johnson remained behind bars for 16 months. They were ultimately released when another man confessed to the murders.

In January, 2009, Calvin Miller of Yoakum County was taken into custody on suspicion of rape and robbery. Once again, Pikett and his dogs were called in to perform a scent lineup to validate police guesswork. Months later, after he was cleared by DNA evidence and an eyewitness identification that pointed elsewhere, Miller finally walked out of jail a free man.

Like Buchanek, he has since filed a civil rights lawsuit in federal court, and he is also represented by Rex Easley.

Jeff Blackburn estimates that 15 to 20 people may be in prison right now "based on virtually nothing but Pikett's testimony." Just how did the dog handler Rex Easley calls "a charlatan" become such a go-to resource for law enforcement? And what do other animal investigation experts say about his methods? Finally, is the widespread use of such dog-scent lineups a legitimate forensic tool, or a form of unreliable "junk science" that has no place in the courtroom? We'll provide answers to these questions as this series continues.



John Browning may be contacted at: jbrowning@thompsoncoe.com

Text Only
Opinion
  • A look at this weekend's opening movies

    BIG MIRACLE

    Marine mammals actually brought about a Cold War thaw.

    February 4, 2012

  • It’s a safe world for judges out there, or is it?

    In a recent survey performed by AOL Jobs using statistics provided by the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the job of judge was rated one of the best “lifestyle jobs”

    February 3, 2012

  • Kindness still goes long way

    Sometimes, a kind gesture or an encouraging word will come out of nowhere and at a time when you least expect it.
    How do I know that?

    February 2, 2012

  • RGB_Marijuana-4_1-26-12.jpg As weird as they wanna be

    Sometimes, the bizarre aspects of the legal world stand out.  There are the outrageous lawsuits, like the convicted drunk driver who sues the family of the motorist he killed or the burglar suing the business he was trying to rob when he hurt himself on their premises.  Then there are the litigants themselves, who often seem like refugees from a bad TV reality show.  Other times, however, you have to dig a little deeper into a police report, an indictment, or a civil suit to arrive at the truly weird kernel at the heart of the matter.  This week, I’d like to bring you my own little roundup of the legally weird.

    January 30, 2012 1 Photo

  • Looking at this weekend's movies

    MAN ON A LEDGE

    Precariously perched on the ledge of the 22nd floor of New York City’s Roosevelt Hotel, ex-cop and fugitive Nick Cassidy (“Avatar” star Sam Worthington) seems poised to jump. But Nick reveals to NYPD negotiator Lydia Anderson (Elizabeth Banks) that he does not intend to commit suicide. Instead, he says that he will remain on the ledge to prove that he is innocent of the crime for which he received a 25-year sentence.

    January 28, 2012

  • Turning over a new leaf to be kinder, gentler

    I want to share with you today about a new leaf that I’ve turned over. I promise to try to be kinder and gentler as often as possible.

    January 26, 2012

  • Bored with the movies? Go to the courthouse instead

    Like many Americans, I had more than my fill of three things this holiday season: turkey, egg nog, and movies.  Not just the big, splashy blockbusters, mind you, like “Mission Impossible: Ghost Protocol,” but also those smaller art-house films that become critical darlings and Oscar favorites.  But now, just as I resign myself to the filmgoer’s malaise that accompanies the string of movies released early in the year that won’t light up the box office or garner golden statuettes, I’ve realized that there is an endless source of almost cinematic entertainment waiting for me down at the courthouse.  So forget your local multiplex

    January 21, 2012

  • To wife Becky: I will be here

     

    It’s no secret that wife Becky and I speak in clichés.

    Our forever favorite is, “The best is yet to come.”

    January 19, 2012

  • RGB_obama1_1-12-12.jpg President Obama’s judicial nominees: A question of qualifications

    One of the many advantages that being president confers is the opportunity to shape the judiciary—potentially for decades to come—through lifetime appointments to the federal bench.

    January 16, 2012 1 Photo

  • A look at this weekend's opening movies

    JOYFUL NOISE

    Blame “American Idol” and its popular offshoots and, of course, “Glee” for sparking the return of the big screen musical.

    January 14, 2012

Featured Ads
House Ads
Poll

Will you vote in the County elections?

Yes
No
     View Results
Facebook

9/11 Remembered
AP Video
White House Attacks Romney on Birth Control Homs Bombardment Continues, Global Outcry Grows Mo. Teen Gets Life Sentence for Killing Girl, 9 Lower-hassle Screening to Be Tested at Airports Raw Video: Dog Rescued From Icy Colo. Water Helmet Camera Captures Calif. Fire Rescue Worker Tells 911: Powell 'exploded the House' Triple Win: Santorum Takes Minn., Mo., Colo. Injured Marine Inspired by Homecoming No Rape Charges Against Son of NYPD Commissioner Egypt's Ruling Generals Play Risky Game With US Former Komen Exec Defends Funding Cut Skip the Coffee Cup and Inhale Your Caffeine Fix Calif. Gay Marriage Ban Ruled Unconstitutional Jury Selection for Ex-UVa Athlete Enters 2nd Day Cab Driver Helps Wis. Family Escape House Fire Staff Removed at LA School During Abuse Probe Runaway Goat Leads Police on Wild Chase
Community Calendar
Loading…
Events by eviesays.com
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Popular Searches
Powered by Local.com